NEW ORLEANS — The athletic facilities at Isidore Newman High School are a quasi-shrine dedicated to the brothers who put it on the map. When you walk in, you’re greeted with a limestone gate that reads “Manning Family Athletic Complex ," which invites you into a stadium that looks more like a mini Division I facility.

Eli Manning is a two-time Super Bowl MVP, but does he have HOF credentials? Here's the case for and against Manning's enshrinement.