Carrie Underwood shared a look at what happened during a commercial break on American Idol on Sunday evening (April 20). Underwood led an a cappella sing-along of “Before He Cheats” with the Idol audience.

American Idol celebrated Easter Sunday with a special “Songs of Faith” episode on Sunday night (April 20), and Carrie Underwood‘s performance was arguably the crown jewel of the whole evening. Underwood sang a sweeping rendition of the traditional Christian hymn “How Great Thou Art,

Carrie Underwood kept it together despite suffering a wardrobe malfunction on stage. Following the incident, the American Idol star celebrated the “fun” and “predictability” of live performances. In addition to being a judge on Idol’s latest season,